Posts

Showing posts with the label NOMA

Karen Armstrong's "The Case for God"

Karen Armstrong is an advocate for NOMA, the principle which says that science and religion involve unique, non-overlapping domains of human interest. In Armstrong's view, each offers a distinct way of finding truth. Science comes from logos , the path of logic, reason, and evidence. Religion, on the other hand, comes from mythos , tapping into the mythological, emotional, intuitive path to wisdom. She believes that religion and science are both necessary for humanity, but that problems arise when either one attempts to invade the other's epistemological territory. Anyone familiar with my views on religion will know that I find this point of view highly problematic. For one thing, it romanticizes both science and religion. More importantly, the distinction is without practical sense. It cannot be justified by appeal to either logos or mythos, and so any disputes cannot be resolved by common agreement. Here are two clever responses to her latest book, The Case for God . ...

Open Letter to "The Reality Club" at Edge.org

Dear Reality Club, I am an atheist and a naturalist. In other words, I do not try to limit our understanding with notions of incomprehensible entities. Like you, I am deeply concerned with the state of science education today. Like many of you, I think religion is best understood scientifically, as a natural phenomenon. As I will argue shortly, the idea of religion and science as non-overlapping magisteria (NOMA) is a hindrance to a better understanding of humanity. Unlike you, I have spoken out in favor of the recent Louisiana legislation which supports teachers who wish to take a critical approach to evolutionary theory in the public classroom. (Much to my surprise, my first article on the subject was heralded by the Discovery Institute. However, I am not surprised that they failed to link to my second article , which details my views on the role of religion in public education.) My reasons for supporting the legislation are simple. Despite the questionable intention...